Last modified by Administrator on 2023/02/17 01:52
From version 5.1
edited by Patrick Masson
on 2015/01/11 22:06
Change comment: There is no comment for this version
To version 1.4
edited by LuisVilla
on 2015/01/11 17:22
Change comment: Created page but still very much a work in progress and may move to another wiki at some point

Summary

Details

Page properties
Author
... ... @@ -1,1 +1,1 @@
1 -XWiki.pmasson
1 +XWiki.LuisVilla
Content
... ... @@ -1,57 +1,41 @@
1 -{{velocity}}
2 - $xwiki.jsfx.use("js/xwiki/table/tablefilterNsort.js")
3 - $xwiki.ssfx.use("js/xwiki/table/table.css")
4 -{{/velocity}}
5 -
6 -(% class="grid sortable filterable doOddEven" id="prospectList" %)
7 -(% class="sortHeader" %)|=Type of selection/specific examples|=Details about selectors|=Terms (or other details)|=Frequency of election?|=Link to more details
1 +|=Type of selection/specific examples|=Details about selectors|=Details about board structure|=Frequency of election?|=Link to more details
8 8  |//**General membership election**//| | | |
9 -|GNOME Foundation|Comprised of Foundation members; members must be contributors to the project; protections against any one company employing more than a certain %age of board members|One year term| Annual| http:~/~/www.gnome.org/foundation/governance/
3 +|GNOME Foundation|Comprised of Foundation members; members must be contributors to the project.|One year term| Annual| http:~/~/www.gnome.org/foundation/governance/
10 10  |Humanitarian Open Street Map|"voting members"- individuals who are contributors to the project; members are nominated by an existing member and confirmed by existing membership|One year term| Annual|http:~/~/wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Humanitarian_OSM_Team/Board_Elections
11 11  |Open Source Geospatial Foundation|"charter members"- individuals who are contributors to the project; members are nominated by an existing member and confirmed by existing membership|?|?|http:~/~/www.osgeo.org/content/foundation/incorporation/bylaws.html
12 12  |Open Street Map Foundation|voting members are anyone who pays the yearly membership fee|?|?|http:~/~/wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Foundation/AGM14/Election_to_Board
13 -|Software in the Public Interest (affiliated with Debian)|"contributing members" (may be individuals or organizations) approved by a membership committee; organizational members have 1 vote each, like individual members|Three year term|Annual; 1/3rd of seats up for election each year|http:~/~/spi-inc.org/corporate/by-laws/
7 +|Software in the Public Interest (affiliated with Debian)|"contributing members" (may be individuals or organizations) approved by a membership committee; organizational members have 1 vote each, like individual members|Two year term|?|http:~/~/spi-inc.org/corporate/by-laws/
14 14  |Apache Software Foundation|Members vote for board; members are all individuals approved by the existing membership on basis of their contribution.|?|?|
15 15  | CACert|Members vote at annual general meeting (held on IRC)|7 members; 3 must be Australian|Annual| https:~/~/wiki.cacert.org/AGM/Next
16 -|Python Software Foundation|Members vote| | | https:~/~/www.python.org/psf/bylaws/
17 -|Gentoo Foundation|Members vote; membership obtained "on request" but membership lapses if no votes are cast in two consecutive board elections|| |
18 -|The Document Foundation (affiliated with the LibreOffice project)|Elected by foundation membership, which is open free of charge to all our contributors, upon review of their
19 - contribution|Two year term| | https:~/~/www.documentfoundation.org/foundation/statutes/
20 -| KDE e.V.|All active members of KDE e.V. get to vote in board elections at annual general meeting|Three year term| Annual|
21 -| | | | |
22 22  |//**Self-selecting board**//| | | |
23 23  |Creative Commons|Community and affiliates may nominate members but do not directly select them|?|?|http:~/~/creativecommons.org/weblog/entry/38704
24 -|Mifos Initiative|Seeded from community leaders and with people invited for their core skills and alignment after initial seeding.| |As needed|
25 -|Benetech|Self-perpetuating board; Founder has right to appoint one member (currently also the Founder)| | | http:~/~/benetech.org/about-us/who-we-are/
26 -|Mozilla Foundation|Elected by existing board| |Annual|https:~/~/static.mozilla.com/foundation/documents/mf-bylaws.pdf
27 -|Software Freedom Conservancy|Elected by existing board| | | https:~/~/sfconservancy.org/about/board/
28 28  | | | | |
29 -| | | | |
30 -|//**External authority**//|e.g., appointed by a single corporation, or by the project/Foundationfounder| | |
31 -|Metabrainz Foundation (affiliated with Musicbrainz project)|President chooses|No term limits | As needed|(((
13 +| //**External authority**//|e.g., appointed by a single corporation, or by the project/Foundationfounder| | |
14 +| Metabrainz Foundation (affiliated with Musicbrainz project)| President chooses|No term limits | As needed| (((
32 32  |http:~/~/metabrainz.org/
33 33  )))
34 -|Free Software Foundation|Founder chooses| | |
35 -| | | | |
36 -| | | | |
37 37  |//**Election by sub-groups**//| | | |
38 -|(none purely with this model; see hybrids below)| | | |
39 39  | | | | |
19 +| | | | |
40 40  |//**Donor election**//|e.g., most 501(c)6s| | |
41 -|(none purely with this model, see hybrids below)| | | |
42 42  | | | | |
43 43  |//**Hybrid model**//|e.g., two or more of the above| | |
44 -|Eclipse Foundation|(Complex system, necessarily simplified) large donors meeting certain criteria can directly appoint board members; classes of smaller donors can vote amongst themselves to appoint some board members; developer and sustaining community members can elect some members in annual election|Depends|Annual for "commiter" (i.e., developer community) members, and "Sustaining" (i.e. typically smaller company) members|https:~/~/www.eclipse.org/org/documents/Eclipse%20BYLAWS%202011_08_15%20Final.pdf
45 -|OpenStack Foundation|2 classes of corporate foundation membership - Platinum
46 - and Gold. Platinum members, of which there are 8, each appoint one board
47 - representative. Gold members, of which there can be a max of 24 select 8
48 - representatives from amongst themselves. Individual
49 - foundation membership is open to anyone with interest, and that
50 - membership class also elects 8 representatives. | |Individual and Gold
51 - member representatives all sit for a one year term.|http:~/~/www.openstack.org/election/2015-individual-director-election/
52 -|Open Source Initiative|Members can be individuals or other organizations; each member class separately nominates board representatives. (For legacy reasons, existing board must approve those nominations, but trying to move towards a model where these are actual elections rather than voting on a nomination.)| | | http:~/~/opensource.org/elections
53 -|Wikimedia Foundation|one founder's seat (reserved for [[Jimmy Wales>>url:http://wikimediafoundation.org/wiki/Board_of_Trustees#Jimmy_Wales]]); two seats selected by the [[Wikimedia chapters>>url:http://wikimediafoundation.org/wiki/Wikimedia_chapters||class="mw-redirect" title="Wikimedia chapters"]]; three seats elected directly by the [[Wikimedia community>>url:http://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Community||class="extiw" title="m:Community"]]; four seats appointed by the rest of the Board for specific expertise| | | http:~/~/wikimediafoundation.org/wiki/Board_of_Trustees
23 +| | | | |
54 54  
55 55  Others not yet in the table:
56 56  
57 -* Linux Foundation
27 +
28 +PostgreSQL can be a survey in itself:
29 +
30 +PostgreSQL.US
31 + Election of membership, who are defined as donors which meet a minimum
32 + level. However, elections are not regularly scheduled.
33 +
34 +PostgreSQL Community Association of Canada
35 + Self-appointing board. All corporation members are also on the board.
36 +
37 +PostgreSQL Europe
38 + Annual general election by certified members.
39 +
40 +JPUG (Japan)
41 + Annual election by local officers of the local chapters.